While talking about the American education system in class today, I started to become frustrated. We talked about how bad the system of quantifying learning and forcing achievement through the numbers destroys the necessities of a playful and happy childhood. We talked about how achievement on standard tests is so worshiped that schools spend hundreds of hours preparing for the test without making sure the kids know the material, comprehend it and ask questions if they aren't sure. Mr. O'Connor described a "bulimic" education system, where kids take in the material, spit it back out, and forget all about it. Some of these themes were described in the film, Race to Nowhere, which is promoting education system changes. A link to the web site for the movie and to change opinions can be found HERE. I have experienced these education problems by forgetting the same material for math tests that I learned for three years in a row. I still don't know how to do a logarithm.
However, as nice as it is to bash the education system, and point out all its flaws, I think this form of argument is flawed. I have always learned that unless I can suggest a better alternative, I shouldn't complain. So I started thinking. One of the problems I encountered was that the mentality of having to perform better than everyone else and out-compete them is ingrained into our society. It scares me to think that if I just let go of everything and enjoyed myself, I may not be able to get a high paying job, or create a good life for my children. I am also afraid of the damage I might inflict on my kids if I don't change my way of thinking a bit. But the obstacles that an activist faces are gigantic! We're talking about a whole overhaul of the way parents and kids envision the future and try to prepare themselves and others who depend on them. This is as big of a change as Martin Luther King Jr. had to face to change people's minds about racism.
So how can a person or even a whole school change things? New Trier, even the whole North Shore, is only a drop in the bucket. But as the Chinese proverb goes, a journey of a thousand miles begins with one step. So clearly change is possible, if improbable. One idea is to start programs at New Trier to educate parents, kids, and faculty about the best education models, and put ourselves on the right track. After that, other schools in the North Shore may look at New Trier's model, and change a bit to help their students grow as people as well as be intelligent. If this model follows, and the Chicago-land area is well know for its positive and well-rounded education, then this idea may show up in the national news. Although it would take a lot of time, I believe change is possible, but only if the hearts of the students are devoted to it.
I believe it would be impossible to change our current education system models. I believe that even while knowing that all the competition we have with each other is bad, no one wants to fall behind. Soon after I showed my mom a video on "A Race to Nowhere", she told me I should quickly sign up for the next ACT test. Although at first I was angry, I realized she too had a point. My parents, along with most parents at New Trier, will pay for my college tuition. She explained to me she didn't want to pay the same amount for me to go to a worse college than I could get into. Although I do not agree with her, and I personally do not like the competition, and the excessive amounts of homework, she's holding all the cards. Parents, want what is best for their kid, and it's what they think is best for the kid, not what the kid thinks is best for themself. The vast majority of parents will keep pressuring their kids to join clubs, take the ACT multiple times, etc., because our society is engrained with competition.
ReplyDeleteIsn't it possible to relax the amount of homework we have and still create a good life for our children? Those two ideas seem very disconnected. Changing the system in place now of constant stress and competition does not necessarily mean going to the complete opposite end of the spectrum and giving up every bit of work ethic we have ever had, it can just mean simple improvements to our school day.
ReplyDeleteI also wonder about your argument that we shouldn't complain unless we can present a better solution. In my opinion, discussing our views of the current system of education is not bashing it, just pointing out what needs to be fixed so that we, as teenagers who have the ability to invoke a change, can begin to suggest alternatives.
I completely agree with Liesel that a more relaxed school day would make all of our lives easier. Unfortunately, there would be some major challenges if New Trier decided to change it's school system to reduce stress. Changing the school system would not be possible unless everyone was on board. If everyone else in the school is taking it easy and then just one person continues to work at the same level they did before and gets into a good college, it will trigger jealousy in everyone else and they will continue to see overworking themselves as a necessity. So I think David is right, a new education model could only work if every student is committed, and that would be highly unlikely.
ReplyDelete